British Columbia has again shown the rest of Canada what forward-thinking justice reform looks like.
On October 1, 2026, B.C. Supreme Court will adopt a new “serve, then file” process for civil and family cases. The change sounds procedural, but it rests on a simple idea that most court systems still haven’t absorbed: the fact that a dispute may need a judge doesn’t mean it must to go before one.
Almost everywhere, including Ontario, it is a tradition that a party who wants a court to decide a legal dispute drafts a court document, files it with the court, books a hearing date and serves the other side. The other side often sees the case for the first time already in court. The dispute is formally in the court system before anyone has read, reflected or picked up the phone.
That order of events rewards escalation, conflict and costs. Once a hearing date is booked, clients brace for battle, positions harden and lawyers prepare to argue. Most of these cases settle somewhere along the way, often on the courthouse steps – but only after the client has suffered cost, stress and delay.
Family law motions are some of the most common and most contested steps in a court case. They cover parenting arrangements, child support, property disputes and money owed, usually on a temporary basis. These temporary orders often become the status quo that shapes everything that follows.
Starting October 1, B.C. reverses that order for family law motions:
- The applicant serves the application materials on the other side first.
- The other side gets time to review and respond.
- A hearing date is booked only if the matter isn’t resolved through that exchange.
- Materials are then filed with the court on set timelines.
The applicant still does the real work. The motion material is drafted, the evidence gathered and the position stated clearly. The other side knows the applicant is serious and prepared to go before a judge. What’s gone is the automatic rush into a courtroom before both sides have seen each other’s case.
Attorney General Niki Sharma states:
“When people are dealing with a family or civil dispute, they want a process that is fair, clear and helps resolve issues as early as possible. These changes encourage people to exchange information sooner, giving them a better opportunity to understand each other’s position, narrow the issues and, where possible, reach a resolution without a court hearing. That means less delay, less stress and more court time available for matters that require a judicial decision.”
The B.C. reform reflects something dispute resolution professionals like Family Mediator/Arbitrators have long understood. Most people don’t want or need a judge to decide their lives. They want a fair result, reached quickly, at a reasonable cost, with their dignity intact. What they often lack is a moment to pause before the machinery of litigation takes over. “Serve, then file” creates that moment. Once both sides have each other’s materials in hand, they have real choices:
- Settle directly. Seeing the other side’s evidence and argument is often enough to show where a reasonable outcome lies.
- Narrow the issues. Even if not everything resolves, the parties can agree on some points and leave only the true disagreements for a decision.
- Move the dispute to private Mediation/Arbitration. This is the choice that will become most common.
When fully prepared documents has been exchanged, the parties already have what a Mediator/Arbitrator needs: clear positions, organized evidence and defined issues. Nothing has to be rebuilt. The work done for court moves straight into a private process that offers what court usually can’t:
- Speed. A Mediation/Arbitration can often be scheduled within days or weeks, not the months a contested hearing can take.
- Confidentiality. Family finances, parenting concerns and personal conflict stay private rather than entering a public court record.
- Control. The parties choose the process, the timing and the decision-maker, and in mediation they write the outcome themselves.
- Durability. Agreements the parties build themselves tend to last longer and produce fewer return trips to court.
As a Family Mediator/Arbitrator, I see every day how much faster and more constructively parties move once someone guides them toward resolution rather than confrontation. B.C.’s reform builds that opportunity directly into the court process itself.
B.C. hasn’t abolished the courts, and it shouldn’t. Some disputes still need a judicial decision. What it has done is recognize that court time is a scarce public resource that should go to the cases that truly need it, and that everyone else deserves a real chance to resolve matters first.
Ontario and the other provinces should pay attention. A rule that asks parties to show their hand before they book a courtroom costs the justice system nothing and could save families a great deal of money, time and conflict.
British Columbia has shown the way again. The question now is who will follow.
This article was recently published in Lexis Nexis’ LAW360 at: https://www.law360.ca/ca/family/articles/2532019/ahead-of-the-pack-b-c-leads-again-by-encouraging-parties-to-try-to-settle-before-coming-to-court
Steve Benmor, B.Sc., LL.B., LL.M. (Family Law), C.S., Cert.F.Med., C.Arb., FDRP PC, Acc.D.C., is a full-time Divorce Mediator/Arbitrator and principal lawyer of Benmor Family Law Group, a boutique matrimonial law firm in downtown Toronto. He is a Certified Specialist in Family Law, a Certified Specialist in Parenting Coordination and was admitted as a Fellow to the prestigious International Academy of Family Lawyers. Steve is regularly retained as a Divorce Mediator/Arbitrator and Parenting Coordinator. Steve uses his 30 years of in-depth knowledge of family law, court-room experience and expert problem-solving skills in Divorce Mediation/Arbitration to help spouses reach fair, fast and cooperative divorce settlements without the financial losses, emotional costs and lengthy delays from divorce court.
Share this article on: