Parenting Assessments (also called Custody Assessments) under section 30 of the Children’s Law Reform Act are commonly used in family law to assist judges in making decisions about parenting schedules for separated parents.
These Assessments, usually conducted by mental health professionals, are meant to provide expert evaluations of the parenting abilities of each parent and the best interests of the child. However, there is mounting evidence that such Assessments have significant flaws that undermine their reliability and usefulness. In fact, the growing body of criticism suggests that these Assessments may do more harm than good in some cases.
One of the most pressing concerns about Parenting Assessments is the fact-finding process. It is not uncommon for Assessors to present reports that are riddled with inaccuracies. In some cases, reports have been discovered to contain data from previous cases or reports that were recycled, creating a false impression of thoroughness. This can include incorrect information about family dynamics, the parties involved, and even misidentifications of children and family members. Such errors are not merely trivial – they can lead to flawed decisions that affect a child’s life and well-being.
The fact-finding process in Parenting Assessments is a human exercise, subject to the natural weaknesses of human error, cognitive bias and selective listening. Assessors can form pre-conceived ideas about a parent from hearing from the other parent first, reading an inaccurate court document or misjudging a poorly prepared intake form. Assessors can pigeon-hole parents based on similar profiles, sometimes due to racial, ethnic or religious factors. Although this rarely occurs with malicious intent, it occurs as a function of the human element of the fact-finding process.
Furthermore, the methodology used in many of these Assessments is often subjective. Who is interviewed, what is read and what weight is placed on collateral information is not transparent or measurable. Evaluators may rely on social science theories or psychological paradigms that may be controversial. Methodologies and theories could fail to account for the unique circumstances of a case, leading to an individual Assessor’s opinion that is defective, and conclusions that are flawed. Similarly, judges may be influenced more by the community reputation of the Assessor than by their work product.
While Assessors may have significant expertise in psychology or mental health, their role should not extend to adjudicating parenting outcomes where the parents disagree. Parenting decisions should ultimately be made by judges, who are trained to weigh evidence and assess witness credibility. However, judges have consistently demonstrated a reliance on Assessments as the “final word” in parenting decisions, thus reducing the judge’s role to that of a passive recipient of an Assessor’s opinion, and hence undermining the integrity of the legal process. Many judges order these Assessments out of convenience, without fully considering whether they are necessary for the particular case. Plus, this inadvertently favours those with the financial means to commission a private evaluation. That is, families with fewer resources may be left at a disadvantage if they cannot afford these Assessments, exacerbating existing inequalities.
Moreover, there is a reluctance by judges to grant pre-trial questioning of the parents and Assessor to test the fact-finding. The absence of pre-trial cross-examination can shield errors from being revealed and lend to the adoption of erroneous findings and flawed recommendations. Assessments consisting of incorrect conclusions about a parent result in devastating consequences for families and legal outcomes that are unjust.
In the State of New York, the Governor established the Blue-Ribbon Commission on Forensic Custody Evaluations in 2021 to consider the impact of flawed Parenting Assessments. After a careful review of the evidence, the Commission recommended the elimination of Parenting Assessments, recognizing the harm that biased and scientifically unsupported evaluations have caused. The findings in New York are invariably present in other jurisdictions, yet hidden.
In Ontario, Assessors are not licenced, regulated or governed. Most Assessors are social workers or psychologists. Although there are many who are highly qualified and provide sage guidance to parents, lawyers and judges, the absence of any regulatory system for Assessors – certification, training, and recertification to ensure that they are applying sound methodologies – can lead to devastating consequences for children, parents and families.
The use of Assessments in family law cases has come under increasing scrutiny due to their flawed methodology, bias, and reliance on incorrect data. As this evidence becomes clearer, it is essential that the legal system reevaluates its approach to these Assessments. Judges should be the decision-makers in contested parenting cases, using Assessments only as one of many tools to gather relevant information, where necessary, stripped of recommendations. While evaluations may still be useful in cases involving clinical issues such as domestic violence, addictions and other mental health concerns, the current approach is suspect. If Assessments and Assessors are to continue to be used in litigated parenting disputes altering the lives of children and families, they must be held to the highest standards of accountability and rigor. Only then can the legal system ensure that parenting outcomes are made with the best interests of the child in mind and without the undue influence of flawed or biased assessments.
Share this article on: